Review by Jill Williamson
In Kathryn Fitzmaurice’s book The Year the Swallows Came Early, eleven-year-old Eleanor “Groovy” Robinson loves cooking. She’s writing her own cookbook and plans to attend culinary arts school someday if she can afford it. Even her best friend Frankie’s stepbrother, who owns a local store, gives her some secret family recipes to go in her special cookbook.
Things start going wrong when her daddy is arrested as they’re walking through town. Since no one will tell Groovy why, she hurries to her momma’s salon to find out. Momma is in no hurry to let Groovy in on the details, but when she finally does explain, the truth breaks Groovy’s heart. Groovy’s sorrow for her daddy evolves into anger and Groovy turns her back on everything that makes her life special: her friends, her family, and her cooking. Nothing matters anymore. But when life brings unexpected surprises, Groovy discovers that there is more to every story. Sure, sometimes people just mess up, but sometimes the situation is out of their control. Either way, Groovy needs to decide if forgiveness is worth the risk.
Having recently read Because of Winn-Dixie, this book felt quite similar. Bother were in first person and about young girls, so I guess that’s why. This book is a great deal longer, but easy to read and entertaining. It’s a character-driven novel, as well. No edge-of-your-seat action adventure in this one. I liked Groovy and the way she saw the world. I liked how she thought her mama’s obsession with horoscopes were just superstitions and didn’t apply her mama’s believes to her own.
I still don’t know why her father was in jail. From what I can figure out, what he did was low and selfish, but completely within his rights as Groovy’s father. I wish the author would have given me a little bit more there to help with the realism of Groovy’s dad’s sentencing, because it didn’t make any sense to me.
My favorite part in the book is when Groovy shows her chocolate-covered strawberries to Marisol, a girl she thought was a bit snobby about her artistic talents. But since Marisol had shared about her love of drawing, Groovy took a chance to reveal a bit of her heart—her love of cooking—and in doing so, Groovy found a great friend. Sometimes friendship is a risk, but isn’t it always a risk worth taking? And if that’s true, isn’t forgiveness a risk worth taking, as well?
Age Range: 8-12
Genre: Contemporary
Part of a Series: No
Pages: 271
Publisher: The Bowen Press (a division of Harper Collins)
Released: 2009
A Christian Worldview of Fiction, All About Children’s Books, Becky’s Book Reviews, Booking Mama, Cafe of Dreams, Dolce Bellezza, Fireside Musings, Homeschool Buzz, Hyperbole, KidzBookBuzz.com, Looking Glass Reviews, Maw Books Blog, Never Jam Today, Novel Teen, Reading is My Superpower
Great review! I think that the reason Groovy’s Dad was arrested and put in jail was because her mother called the police and turned him in for stealing (the money that was suppose to go to Groovy) Since stealing is a crime, that is the reason he was in jail for a bit of time – at least that is what I took away from it, as far as the reason.
I enjoyed this book too.
Thank you for this lovely review. One of my favorite chapters has always been, “The Part of Marisol That Shines”, and so I’m really happy you enjoyed that one, too!
Great review!
I agree with April. The man stole Groovy’s money. I just assumed that it was in some kind of trust for her and he hadn’t the legal right to take it. Interesting question. I saw in the the acknowledgements some thanks to someone in the police department so I assumed the author researched this stuff.
I also thought of Winn Dixie when I read this. And The Giver and Wrinkle in Time. I think this book stands out as a book with depth and voice and I have a feeling that Kathryn Fitzmaurice is going to be a household name before long.